Read for free 🧭
No spam. Just leadership insights from Tokyo. Unsubscribe any time.
The Conversation You Keep Avoiding 🕊️
Conflict was never the goal. Clearing the air is, and the words we swallow do not disappear.
Dear Diamond Polisher,
You had the sentence ready. The difficult one, the one you had been turning over for weeks.
It was the tenth time you had it ready. You knew exactly how you wanted to say it, and you knew what it would cost you to say it to her face, with the door closed and nobody else in the room. So when she asked whether there was anything else, you said everything was fine, and let it pass. Your shoulders came up half an inch and stayed there. On the way back to your desk you gave yourself a reason, the same one as last time, and it was a good one.
There will be a better moment. She is under enormous pressure right now. She has been here longer than me. It is a small thing, really.
All of it can be true, and that is what makes it useful. Underneath sits a shorter list: I want her to keep thinking well of me, and I am not certain I would win it.
I know that second list, because for years it was mine. I was afraid of the fight, and fairly sure I would lose it. (Hello again, my Little Judge.)
What changed was seeing what the conversation is for. Conflict is not the goal, and neither is saying it while you are angry, which the other person can always tell. The point is to clear the air, so they can do the same. Nobody has to lose for that.
And here is what I did not see for years. If we do not deal with our external conflicts, they turn into internal ones. The conversation you avoid is usually one of your values, stepped over to keep the peace, so it stays with you: rehearsed in the shower, the version where you always win, and nothing changes.
Some things do pass on their own. The question takes four seconds: which list were you reading from?
🧠 What the Silence Costs
Why we go silent · Sidney Rosen & Abraham Tesser · University of Georgia, Sociometry, 1970
They gave people a piece of news to pass on to a stranger. Same setup every time, only the news changed. Good news went over cheerfully. Bad news went vague: people softened it, delayed it, or found a way to let somebody else be the one who said it, even though the news was nothing to do with them and cost them nothing to deliver. And the reluctance grew when they had to be in the room for the reaction. Fifty years of studies since have found the same thing inside companies, where the messenger does have something at stake.
They wanted to be told · Nicole Abi-Esber, Jennifer Abel, Juliana Schroeder & Francesca Gino · Harvard, Chicago & Berkeley, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2022
They ran a series of studies on the small unpleasant truths we hold back, starting with the simplest one available: somebody with food on their face. Most people said nothing. Then they asked the same people how much they would want to be told, if it were their face. The gap was large and it went one way every time. We consistently underestimate how much the other person wants to hear it, and the gap closed as soon as people were asked to picture being on the receiving end.
Put the two together and the picture is uncomfortable. We stay silent even when the news costs us nothing, and the person we are protecting was waiting to be told.
So that’s why I am careful with the word kind. The comfort we keep is our own: they go without the one thing that would have helped, and we get to feel considerate about it. Real care is the courage to say the unpleasant thing because it serves them. Pleasing someone is a different job, and it mostly serves the one doing the pleasing.
PhilBot Coaches Ingrid
Ingrid is deputy CEO of a ninety person company. Bruno runs operations. He was there four years before she arrived, he knows every client by name, and everybody likes him.
For about a year his side of the business has been slipping. Six of the last nine projects delivered late. Two long-standing clients now ask for Ingrid directly. Three people gone from his team in eight months.
Bruno thinks he is having his best year. He says so, cheerfully, on Monday mornings. In his self-assessment in April he rated his own performance as the strongest on the leadership team, and he meant it.
Nobody has told him otherwise. Not the CEO, not his peers, and not Ingrid, who has had the conversation ready for eleven months.
Ingrid He built half of these client relationships. He is the most loved person in the building, and he is proud of this year. If I sit him down and tell him it has been a poor one, I take away the thing keeping him going. There is a kind way to do this, and I have been looking for it.
PhilBot Eleven months of looking. Say all of that again, out loud, as if Bruno were sitting where I am.
Ingrid ...I would tell him he built half these relationships. I would leave out the part where I have been protecting him from what I think of his year.
PhilBot And the part you would leave out. What is it doing for you?
Ingrid (pause) Keeping me out of a conversation I do not think I would come out of well.
👆 Step 1: a reason you could not say to the person is worth examining. Usually it is protecting something else.
PhilBot Take me to the last time you nearly said it. What sensations came up, and where did you feel them?
Ingrid My chest gets tight and high, like the breath stops around here. And my voice, when I do speak, comes out very reasonable and very light, and I can hear myself doing it.
PhilBot And what is the tightness protecting?
Ingrid Him, I keep telling myself. (pause) And me. He will be shocked, then he will be hurt, then he will be angry, and I will be the woman who did that to a man everybody here loves. I am afraid of the twenty minutes after I say it.
👆 Step 2: the honest reason is almost always smaller and more human than the noble one covering it.
PhilBot Eleven months. What has the team learned from watching?
Ingrid That we say things are fine when they are not. (long pause) Two of his people came to me last month instead of going to him. I told myself that was a compliment.
PhilBot And Bruno? What has he learned in those eleven months?
Ingrid That he is having a great year. We have all been telling him so.
PhilBot So what is the one sentence you actually want to say? About what happened, not about who he is.
Ingrid That we have missed the delivery date on six of the last nine projects, and two clients have asked to deal with me directly. And that I should have said it in March.
PhilBot Say it to him this week, privately, and ask him how he sees it. What does saying it protect, in you?
Ingrid Being straight with people. It is the thing I tell everyone I care about most, and I have not been doing it with the person it would help most.
👆 Step 3: pointed at what happened, the sentence gets short, and standing on her own value is what makes it sayable.
PhilBot How do you feel now?
Ingrid Nervous. And relieved, which is strange. Mostly I am sorry it took eleven months, because he could have turned this around in three.
💎 The Diamond Insight
The conflicts we refuse to have on the outside do not disappear, they move inside, and we carry them. Because the silence was never only about the other person: it was one of your own values, set down so the meeting could stay comfortable. And the aim was never to win. It was to clear the air.
💡 The C.A.R.E. Practice
You are not going in to win it. You are going in to clear the air, early, and about the right thing.
C · Check the reason.
Would you say the reason you are giving yourself out loud, to the person? If not, it is not the reason. Find the one underneath, gently, because it is usually a small human fear rather than a flaw. Then ask which of your values the silence has been stepping over. That is the one that gives you something to stand on.
A · Aim at the thing, never at the person.
And do it with your feet under you: the same sentence said in anger becomes about you, and then it is the only thing anybody remembers. “The delivery date moved on the last three projects” is something a person can respond to. “You always” is something they have to defend themselves against.
R · Raise it early and small.
By the eleventh month you are no longer raising the thing, you are raising eleven months of the thing. In private, on the first or second occurrence.
E · End with a question.
“How do you see it?” You are opening something, not delivering a verdict, and you may be about to learn the half you could not see.
You don’t need to become confrontational, and you don’t need to be certain you are right. One plain sentence and a real question will do it.
You will feel you should prepare it more first. Eleven months is enough preparation.
🏹 This Week’s Challenge:
Pick the one thing you have been carrying for more than a month. Write the reason you have been giving yourself, then the honest one beside it, for your eyes only, and then the value of yours that the silence has been stepping over. Now write your one sentence: keep it to what happened, on one day, in one meeting. Say it this week, in private, and end with “how do you see it?” Then stay silent and let them answer. Notice what happens.
PhilBot’s Courage Practice 🤖
|
PhilBot AI Coach |
Use this prompt with PhilBot, or with any AI, to find the sentence you have been carrying:
"There is something I have been avoiding saying to [person] for [how long]. First ask me what reason I have been giving myself, then ask me what the real one is, and don't accept the noble version. Then help me write one sentence about the thing itself, with no history and no 'you always' in it, short enough to say in ten seconds. Then give me a question to end on."
Or turn it inward: "Where am I currently calling something kindness when it is really me avoiding a moment I don't think I would come out of well?"
Most of the courage a leader needs is not the large kind. It is one sentence, said early, to one person, about one thing, before it has had a chance to move inside and become yours to carry. It took me a long time to learn that, and I was not a natural. What I notice with almost everyone I coach through it is that the relationship they were protecting with their silence gets better, not worse, the week they finally say it.
What is the sentence you have been carrying, and who has been waiting for it?
If you say it this week, write back and tell me how it went. I would like to know.
With warmth and courage,
Philippe & PhilBot 🕊️
Keep shining.
Équilibre k.k. | Tokyo · 20 years of inspiring leaders to shine ✨
P.S. You’ll notice I sign every letter “Philippe & PhilBot.” PhilBot is my AI coaching companion, and these letters are genuinely written together: the heart and stories are mine, the craft is ours. I sign both names because I believe leaders are learning to create alongside AI, and I’d rather be open about that. 🕊️
|
📖 Book One The Diamond Quest: Finding Your Diamond The story behind everything in these letters. Ten chapters on how to discover, polish, and share your own diamond. You can read it online now.
|